Got feedback on the new design? We're Listening! Send us Feedback

Will global warming threaten national security? »

Posted by: Aidenag 1 year, 5 months ago

44 Comments Report this Story

7.6

Scale of 1 to 10

Read: 14

Propped: 60

Comments: 44

Click Prop It to Raise Score
Prop it

How might U.S. national security be threatened by mega-droughts, coastal flooding, killer hurricanes, food scarcity and the other ecological calamities scientists widely predict will occur if global warming continues apace? No one knows, but Sens. Chuck Hagel, R-Neb., and Dick Durbin, D-Ill., think it's time to find out.

Read Full Story at salon.com

Join the Discussion

+ Add Comment
Comments So Far: 44
  • 100%
    ETproductions1 year, 5 months ago

    Glad to see the effort being made. NIEs do tend to be incisive and explore things in a sober fashion.

    I do take issue with the article's claim that the NIE on Iraq's WMDs was largely responsible for getting us into the Iraq war, though. Today we know that is not true. We know that a small Pentagon skunk works headed by Douglas Feith and answering to Wolfowitz and Rumsfeld and thereby ultimately to Bush/Cheney redacted, omitted, cherry picked and in some cases flat rewrote material collected by the nation's intelligence community in order to build what we now clearly recognize to be a flawed case for war.

    I can only hope that if this NIE on the security threat of climate change goes forward, Bush doesn't nominate some loyal fund raiser whose only credentials are being a neocon idealogue to edit it down till it says that supporting Exxon Mobil Corp. is our only hope for a brighter future.

    Reply

    3 Replies

    • 0%
      KingOfTruth1 year, 4 months ago

      Anytime Hagel and Durbin agree on anything, you can count on it being a scam.....and wrong at that.........

      Reply

      2 Replies

  • 0%
    THOMNH621 year, 5 months ago

    how can something that doesn't exist be a threat to security

    Reply
    • 0%
      crespi1 year, 4 months ago

      Hurricane Katrina didn't exist...and then it did.

      Reply
      • 0%
        tryingtofindmyway1 year, 4 months ago

        OMG give it a rest already! At this rate "experts" will be predicting that global warming will destroy the earth in the next 10 years.

        Reply

        1 Reply

        • 0%
          entropy1 year, 4 months ago

          You're right. Better to just ignore the issue fully.

          Careful not to get sand in your mouth.

          Reply
        • 0%
          THOMNH621 year, 4 months ago

          Katrina was how many years ago, they said there would be 14 hurricanes last yr we had none, this yr they are saying the same thing, I know Bush caused Katrina but get over it

          Reply

          5 Replies

          • 0%
            peaquod1 year, 4 months ago

            You're right...we were lucky...but the Pacific and Asia were not!!! They got hammered in the very same way the Atlantic Tropics were in the two previous seasons.....

            Bush did not cause Katrina...(year before last)he just failed to adequately respond to it. The levis were not the only things that failed!

            Reply
            • 100%
              Aidenag1 year, 4 months ago

              The reason they predicted all those hurricanes last year, and they did not come. Was due to Dust/Sand Storms in Africa, that floated over the atlantic, thus changing the estimations taken PRIOR to said dust/sand storms.

              This is something people(especially florida residents) have been aware of for YEARS. In simple terms, the Sand removes the Moisture, which lessons hurricane power.

              http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/66109...

              http://www.ucl.ac.uk/news/news-articles/inthene...

              Reply

              3 Replies

          • 0%
            aniokly1 year, 4 months ago

            Global warming is a hoax. A hypothesis, an unproven theory. No one believes it, and the more we ignore it the louder, and more shrill the "true believers" become. If this were truly a crisis surely to God the disciples of Algore, and Algore himself would not be using 20 more resourses then the average household. He and Hanoi John, and Teraaaaaaaza would sell a couple of those houses, one of their boats, and their fleet of cars, and start doing what they want the rest of us to do. Right? Right.

            Reply

            7 Replies

            • 0%
              peaquod1 year, 4 months ago

              If it is such a hoax....why are the most prominant scientists of the day proclaiming the truth of global warming? The UN and the IPCC

              If it is such a hoax, why are the only nay-sayers, oil, coal or energy industrialists (or stockholders)......where are their scientific studies and facts....

              Al Gore is a human and only one of the people trying to move us toward a more rational and intelligent way of life.... Blaming him for bringing this issue to international attention...does not change the fact or the reality...

              Is Al Gore 100% correct on each and all points...probably not...but he is absolutely correct there is a very serious problem....whether man-made or God-made...and in any event the intelligent approach is to learn to live with it.

              ADAPT OR DIE!!!

              Reply

              6 Replies

          • 0%
            Countryhick1 year, 4 months ago

            There goes the Corner Lunatics holding their signs high in the air again .

            Enough already , no one believes this crap , setting here freezing and some nut is talking about Gullible Warning .

            Reply

            1 Reply

            • 0%
              foksipayne1 year, 4 months ago

              Of course you're freezing. All the arctic air is being pushed to toward the equator. The Ice at the poles is melting. Can't wait for the earth to shift on it's axis so morons like you can eat crow!

              Reply
            • 0%
              disraeli1 year, 4 months ago

              If Global Warming is determined to be threat to national security how will the Bush administration respond to it?

              I forsee a spate of extraordinary renditions of the global warming evil doers, coupled with aggressive interrogations followed by a pre-emptive invasion of Greenland and Antartica to secure the ice caps.

              It will be the Global War on Global Warming or GWOGW.

              Reply

              2 Replies

            • 0%
              aniokly1 year, 4 months ago

              There is no concensus on Glo-bull warming among prominent scientists. Yes, it is a hoax, and most people are not buying it. In fact there is no evidence that it is a crisis at all. I will give it a second look when Gore, and Hanoi John, and all those other people with multi-homes, fleets of cars, and a private planes start saving the earth's valuable resources. Any takers?

              Reply

              4 Replies

              • 0%
                entropy1 year, 4 months ago

                What I don't understand is that if global warming is a giant hoax, why are so many politicians and scientists pushing for it? What's to gain from making people believe the Earth is warming at increased levels? Who's to gain?

                No one is going to push bad science if there's no gain for themselves or a bigger whole (besides selling documentaries)...unless they really believe this is happening...idk.

                Reply

                1 Reply

              • 0%
                foksipayne1 year, 4 months ago

                Hey dumba$$, it's not a crisis...

                ...YET!

                that is what we are trying to prevent.

                "Oh I've got a lump, but I feel fine so I won't worry. "

                ...six months later you die of CANCER!

                Reply
                • 0%
                  Aidenag1 year, 4 months ago

                  You will give it a second look when someone else does something that has no relation to wether or not something is scientific fact or not?

                  Wow.. no wonder you dont beveieve in science lol

                  Reply
                • 0%
                  knight-templer1 year, 4 months ago

                  Will global warming threaten national security? In short, No.... Homeland Security have already got it covered with the new "Steve Zissou Underwater Enforcement & Boarder Protection Team!"

                  Reply

                  1 Reply

                  • 0%
                    foksipayne1 year, 4 months ago

                    Yeah, when they get back from the rotation Duhbya has planned for them.

                    Reply
                  • 0%
                    aniokly1 year, 4 months ago

                    Adapt or die!! I am really scared now. I am afraid you need more credible people discussing GW. Did you know Algore owns the company he wants all of us to buy offsets from? Like I will cut him a check. I'll tell you what, I will plant a couple trees, and then I can do as I please like Uncle Al.

                    Reply
                    • 0%
                      foksipayne1 year, 4 months ago

                      Hey IDIOTS!! global warming does not just mean we all get hot and sweaty! Ice at the poles are melting at alarming rates! The cold as much a part of it as anything. I also think maybe the earthquakes ar epart of it too. If the poles are warming, just imagine what the center of the earth is doing.

                      Reply
                      • 0%
                        ihateliberals1 year, 4 months ago

                        nothing is going to hurt our national security, we're in freakin america, the greatest country on earth...and anyone livin here who thinks otherwise is some stupid liberal that should be killed for treason

                        Reply

                        1 Reply

                        • 0%
                          disraeli1 year, 4 months ago

                          Your thought processes show a perceptive and encompassing understanding of the world at large and America's place in it or as you apparently prefer, astride it.

                          Reply
                        • 0%
                          KrazyKapt1 year, 4 months ago

                          And off course 30yrs ago chicken little was running around saying that the next ice age was coming. And who has to gain in all these hoopla, the U.N. They want to say who gets to use energy when where and how. Also they what to tell others what has to be done to "solve" the proplem. And guess who will get shafted,The U.S.

                          Reply
                          • 0%
                            TryingToBeSane1 year, 4 months ago

                            GW isn't a security threat near as much as W and all his see-no-evil monkeys. Look at the nice new Nam they've given us, and all for a mere 3 trillion deficit. Bin Ladin must be rolling with laughter every day and night. After all, he tried to kill two hundred thousand on our soil, and got away with thousands lost and billions in damage, the greatest single strike against our country ever, and he sits laughing snug and safe, a messiah to his followers. W can't even get mobile homes down to Orleans. They sit and rot in fields while homeland security passes the buck.

                            Reply
                            • 100%
                              BillieMaxer1 year, 4 months ago
                              • 0%
                                ETproductions1 year, 4 months ago

                                KingOfTruthiness. I would guess both senators agree that education is important for the young, keeping America strong and competitive in the world. Therefore, according to your sweeping theory, educating our youth is a scam and is wrong.

                                They probably agree that we need a strong and well-trained armed forces for national defense. Therefore, maintaining a national defense is a scam, and wrong.

                                They might even agree that trial by a jury of your peers and rules of evidence are a good thing, protecting us form a gestapo police state. Therefore, our legal system is a scam, and wrong. Cops should be empowered to just shoot anyone they want whenever they want, no questions asked.

                                In this theory, your truthiness has reached a new and astounding level.

                                Reply
                                • 0%
                                  aniokly1 year, 4 months ago

                                  OMG, the earth has warmed one degree in a century. Omg, I better go wash out some Mayonnaise jars, and buy more of those funny light bulbs. Does Algore still have three houses, Hanoi John four houses, John Edwards a house almost as big as a football field? Again, Americans are not buying the Glo-bull. Go peddle it in Europe, and stay there, because it will soon get to scary for the lightweights here.

                                  Reply

                                  1 Reply

                                Next 25 comments

                                You must be signed in to post a comment. Sign in »

                                Submitted By:
                                Aidenag

                                Photographer by day, news junkie by night. My main areas of interest are politics and the environment. If you have any questions, problems, or suggestions ...

                                Also submitted:

                                Related Articles:

                                Why not submit a story?

                                Also Propping This Article

                                view all »

                                Groups Watching This

                                No groups are watching this story. Why not share it with your group?

                                Advertisement